Saturday, September 22, 2018

A Whiff of Self-Liberation





Peaks dancing

a steady granite

zigzag jig



the sky bowing down to

to touch flower heads

on mountain slopes



given together

sky-mountain

mountain-flower



into the luminous

a butterfly spreads its wings

the air smells fresh


c Choyin Dorje/Matthias Dehne 2018




Friday, September 14, 2018

How Lama Dawa Became My Mother’s Guide


The development unfolded gradually over a five year period and it was beautiful to observe, especially when understanding it fully now by looking back, for all the love and care that it involved and expressed.  Lama Dawa never met my mother in person, but for all intents and purposes she became his student, albeit unbeknownst to her.  And, in a manner of speaking he played the part of a devotee, as it became more and more apparent how fully devoted he was to her welfare—how all these little hints and pointers of his culminated in liberating action at the time of death.  In this sense, any true teacher becomes a devotee, devoted to his or her dharma friends’ welfare, and unreservedly so.

Much of what transpired between Lama and my mother happened through mirror divinations, which is also how it got started.  The year was 1999, the month of December to be exact.  I had arrived a month earlier, with the intention to stay into April 2000 because of the full cycle of bKa-Ma transmissions and empowerments to be given at a Nyingma monastery in Tinchuli beginning after Losar 2000.  Lama had insisted that I take part, overriding my objection that I would anyway be able to practice only a fraction of what was to be given.  This being a fact my protestation was, why bother at all?  He didn’t accept this, replying that I needed the entire lineage and not just bits and pieces.  When he spoke like this with the voice of absolute guru authority, ‘no’ was never an option.

About a month after my arrival, on the occasion of my weekly phone call to Germany I heard from my mother that she had been diagnosed with more cancer, this time in the other breast and that she would have to undergo surgery the coming Monday in the early morning hours.  I believe I made the call on a Friday.  My mother didn’t request me to come, but it was obvious that as her sole close relation alive (after all she was already 85 years old at the time), I would need to go. 

That same afternoon I went to see Lama Dawa and told him all about it.  His reaction was, “We have to consult the mirror immediately.”  Which he did.  But he ignored my readiness to go and book a flight, immediately.  Instead, he was totally focused on arranging whatever needed to be done.  At that time he was at home in the old Kathmandu house by himself, with only his daughter Rigzin, as he had sent the khandros Kalsang & Kunzang together on a pilgrimage to India.  Economical as ever with words in important matters he stated,  Two pujas have to be done tomorrow, and Lama Yedrol will do them for your mom and then there is something else that only I can do, and I will do it in the night.”  This was about all of the information that he volunteered.  He called Lama Yedrol on the phone and then sent me over to his place to make the required offering. 

In addition Lama instructed me not to call Germany on Saturday, but only to get in touch with my mother in the hospital on Sunday after the last pre-operation tests and check-ups.  I didn’t understand why, but I nevertheless did as I had been told. 

Reaching the woman at the reception desk, I asked for my mother.  She took a while to find the room number, but then replied, “Your mother has been discharged an hour ago.  You can probably reach her at home by now.”  I made the call, and yes, my mother was in her apartment.  Excited even agitated as she obviously was she was almost tripping over her own words, “Would you believe it, son, they checked my breast again, and there was absolutely no lump.  They found this quite strange because only a week ago there had been one, and not too small.  And they had the records to prove it.  They then murmured something about an unbelievable spontaneous remission and let me go.”  Well, may be the remission hadn’t been just spontaneous after all.  May be it had to do with some unknown skillful intervention.  We will never know.  Anyhow, I wouldn’t have to fly to Germany. 

Every year after this happened, whenever I visited Lama in Kathmandu, he did something for my mother.  And mostly he initiated the action himself.   I remember one time, when she had confessed to me that she was becoming increasingly depressed because several of her friends had passed.  While listening to me telling him, Lama nodded, did another divination without my even asking for it and then suggesting, “Now that she has lost some of her friends, she needs Tara as a friend.  I will send Tara to her myself.”  Which, again, he did!

Come to think of it, many of the interventions for her sake he insisted on doing himself, rather than commissioning another Lama.  Whenever I called her after ‘Tara had been sent’, the depressed undertone in my mother’s voice was gone.  I believe this was in 2002.  It took me a while to discern it because it was quite subtle, but whenever Lama spoke about my mother, his voice sounded even more loving than usual.  Which, of course cannot be read as a claim to exclusivity.  Whenever Lama was lovingly focused on someone that person automatically felt special.  In this sense, all the people whom Lama Dawa ever fully focused on, for that moment of his focusing, became the same kind of ‘special’.

In 2003 I could not see Lama Dawa because he did not return to Kathmandu for over an entire year, but I was able to call him a few times, either from India or Germany.  On one of these occasions he stated out of the blue, “Choyin Dorje, you cannot let your mother die in Germany.  It is absolutely necessary that she dies in India, in your house.  I will help you to get her there.  First I will send you a small Guru Rinpoche picture that you have to place somewhere in the room where she spends most of her time.”  I interjected that knowing her I was quite certain she would throw the picture into the waste bin.  He remained unfazed, “She won’t notice it.  But it has to be near her.  Later that same year when back on another visit in Germany, sure enough I received an envelope with a small Guru Rinpoche image from and blessed by Lama in the US and placed it on the China cabinet next to the TV set.  As Lama had predicted, my mother didn’t comment which means she hadn’t noticed, as otherwise comments would have been made, and neither too few nor too pleasant!  My mother strongly disapproved of anything religious that wasn’t Lutheran, and she especially detested my involvement with these eastern lama or guru types.

I met Lama again in Kathmandu, shortly after Losar in 2004.  He reiterated his previous command (yes, and a command it had been, no doubt) to get my mom to India, soon.   I had some reservations doubts and voiced them, like my mom being blessed with the mindset of a staunch white supremacist and therefore she would never move to a country full of colored people. Lama didn’t honor this with an answer.  Bring her to India.” But he said it very softly, with a deeply half pacifying and half seductive voice, not harshly.  This time he elaborated further.  Once she is with you in India, she will pass on very soon.  She cannot die in Germany.  She has to die in India.  It is your duty to make it happen.

I didn’t deliberate further.  I finally took Lama’s word for it.  When back in South India after my return from Nepal I called her up and said, “Listen mom, we are going to move to Goa in the fall or early winter where we will rent a bigger house.  I would like you to come and live with us.”  I had expected a resounding rejection, but was surprised to hear something like, “That would be lovely.  Sure I will come.”  I couldn’t believe what I just heard, but of course I did. 

Despite of all of Lama’s hints my mother’s positive answer t the invitation had still taken me by surprise, and the fact that it did, illustrated unfortunately, how little I had grasped of who Lama Dawa really was!

The vastness of his view that was all-knowing, whenever he wanted it to be! 

Past & future did not exist for him in these instances; although I should probably write DO NOT exist for him even now, as now he is omnipresent.

(to be concluded)



 

Sunday, September 9, 2018

Defining Buddhist Yoga



“When we say ‘naljor’, which is the Tibetan word for yoga, we are referring to a path that opens up the ‘wealth of being natural’.  In India or in Tibet, we call practitioners or meditators yogis, meaning individuals, who have this wealth or richness of being natural.”



-DZONGSAR JAMYANG KHYENTSE





Buddhist yoga is an integral part of the Buddhist path, along which according to tradition, the Buddha makes available 84,000 ways, or in other words as many ways as there are beings in this limitless universe, to relieve all these beings from suffering— and not only from one type of suffering, but all kinds and types of suffering.  This is thus also the main purpose of Buddhist yoga: to relieve all kinds and types of suffering—not only for the benefit of the individual practitioner, but rather working through the individual practitioner, for the benefit of all beings.



What makes beings like us suffer, either overtly or in hidden ways?  What is the cause for our fundamental suffering of birth, sickness, old age and death that all living beings share?  Of dissatisfaction, depression, fatigue, unfortunately common to most humans?  The Buddha names ignorance as the root or our fundamental lack of understanding of what is real and what is not.



May be we could say that we suffer because we try to fit the vastness of this ever-present, yet ever shifting luminous blissful space of all that ever manifests, as well as all that remains non-manifest, into the tiny room of our preconceived ideas, concepts and beliefs.  We make our worlds, our scope of exploration and experience, our minds much smaller than they are.  It is as if we were to try and compress countless galaxies with innumerable solar systems, plus the vast spaces between them, into a small bathroom bucket—in order to practically handle and manipulate them according to our short-lived whims, which also constantly change.  Of course, such approach will never work.  The bucket is way too small, and its walls are too inflexible.  And since our whims change, whatever we put together in the confines of the bucket starts falling apart in the moment of putting it together, already.  Everything eventually feels cramped.  Nothing can fully satisfy.  Any moment of satisfaction quickly turns into dissatisfaction.



By practicing Buddhist yoga we open the walls of the bucket.  We return to the universe, in a manner of speaking.  We relax, and in the process of ever deepening relaxation eventually are able to directly see that there is no such bucket, that there aren’t any walls that restrict awareness, to begin with.  In and through awareness, what actually is spontaneously recognizes itself, thus liberating itself.  We recognize who and what we are truly are, and what in fact is the authentic state of all that is always accessible, in every moment.  The outside conditions in the way we experience our everyday world eventually may change, too.  But what is mostly fine-tuned and actualized, is our view, our way of seeing.  Everything else happens from there.



This process from rigidity and artificial restriction through relaxation to awareness is inferred by the Tibetan word ‘naljor’ for the Sanskrit word ‘yoga’, reaching far beyond a narrow literal translation.  Yoga simply means ‘union’.  Naljor’, the Tibetan rendering, on the other hand, also points to what kind or quality of union is achieved through this yoga.  According to the Tibetan master Namkhai Norbu, the syllable ‘nal’ refers to the original state, whereas ‘jor’ means to discover or possess this condition.  Accordingly, the true meaning of the word ‘naljor’ is to discover our real condition.”[1] 



Therefore, Buddhist yoga is not predominantly about health and fitness but about exploring what is happening, what is unfolding before us and inside.  What is the mind and what does it project?  Who is projecting?  This approach will turn out to be far more liberating than anything we have experienced so far.  Health and fitness are welcomed as secondary benefits.



Dzongsar Jamyang Khyentse as already quoted in the lead in paragraph to the chapter, stresses a different aspect of the same process: its inherent richness.  According to his interpretation, “‘nal’ means ‘being natural’, and ‘jor’ points to the wealth and richness inherent in and expressing through that state of totally acting and being natural.”[2] 



The ordinary human mentality resembles that of a beggar.  Very few feel inherently rich and blessed, no matter how much or how little money, or other possessions they have.  Even a billionaire most likely will act and behave like a beggar, because there is never enough.  There might be enough money all right, but then a deplorable lack of full spectrum control is diagnosed.  However, the nagging question arises, if I don’t exercise complete control, I might lose what I have.   It then becomes only logical that I have to increase my tools and levels of control.  This shows that a billionaire’s mindset is indeed also that of a beggar, nothing lofty or elevated. 



The sense of palpable richness rests in simplicity.  All true yogis are simple people at heart.  If they appear complex and hard to understand from the outside, then only because they mirror back the student’s inner perplexities and complexities.  Genuine mediators are genuinely relaxed.  That is the kind of richness that we would want to experience, and easily can experience.  We can feel rich living in a palace.  We can feel equally rich living in a mountain cave.  We can have oodles of money, and let it all go.  And we can have little money, and let more come according to the dictate of the situation.  Whatever comes never adds to our sense of status.  It is to enhance our ability to act skillfully and wisely.  Whatever leaves does not diminish us, or our sense of status. 



As one Tibetan yogi whom I had the privilege to meet many times used to repeat like a mantra when explaining how to handle outer wealth, “Ram jao, Ram ao”, he said.  In English, “God comes [as He wishes] and God leaves [as He wishes]."  Don’t cling, don’t interfere, and don’t get sticky.  Whatever comes let it come!  Whatever goes let it go! This way, wealth is enjoyable, as everything is enjoyable because we act naturally.  According to Namkahi Norbu’s reading of the word ‘naljor’ or yoga, this is a sign that “we trust our real condition”.   



Thus by focusing on the aspect of our real condition, Namkhai Norbu stresses the link that exists between the practice of Buddhist yoga and its scriptural foundation.  Especially the Ati Yoga teachings are focused on the true state of affairs and make accessing it practically possible.  Dzongsar Jamyang Khyentse on the other hand tries to point to how practicing this yoga might actually feel like to the practitioner.  Practicing yoga and meditation makes us feel rich and blessed because we can feel natural, unburdened.  When embodying and operating through direct, spontaneous, and irrepressible knowingness, we can rightfully call ourselves yogi or yogini.  When still trapped into the phantasmagoria of ‘separate self’ versus ‘world outside’, plus all the thoughts and emotions ensuing from such view, we are not really yoga practitioners but only aspire to be.  When we hold back and don’t explore into the fundamental reality of mind-body-world interconnectedness, opening ourselves to and into its primordial basic openness, we are actually selling ourselves short.  The fundamental openness of mind, reflected in the openness of our living and acting in the world, is where unconditioned bliss awaits.  This is why Dzongsar Jamyang Khyentse speaks of ‘richness & wealth’.




[1] Chogyal Namkhai Norbu, Yantra Yoga – The Tibetan Yoga of Movement, Ithaka, New York, 2008, p 11
[2] Dzongsar Jamyang Khyentse, from a FB posting based on an unspecified teaching transcript

Friday, September 7, 2018

This Darn Vajra Guru Thing





This entire life

I have been trusting in the Vajra Guru



I had faith in him beginning in childhood

when the feeling welled up without face or name



yet he always remained my hidden diamond in this mere phantom appearance

refracted through a thousand broken shards of bewilderment year after year



before I met any of his manifestations in the flesh

I had painted him life-size on my apartment wall towering



in storm and rain & hail from the darkness of my unenlightened heart

I felt as if I was indeed circling with his dancers celebrating



at which moment the faith of the inner sky merged with the faith of

the outer sky to forever remain with the invincible



in person



I met the Vajra Guru as the perfect monk of yore

speaking in hushed tones as if every word was soft as honey

and every syllable the jewel of absolute such-affirming truth



I met the Vajra Guru in public wearing a black hat

& in private pointing out the great seal through every pore

his body as pliant as a giant baby of the forever unborn as it manifests



I met the Vajra Guru as the perfect tamer of beings

even though he wore dirty slacks  to a cheap Chinese house robe

& his hair was unwashed with an oily shine & his voice screeched



I met the Vajra Guru introduced by others as the perfect yogi

with whom I never knew how to communicate except wordlessly

but still he blessed me much and sealed me in retreat



I met the Vajra Guru as the best of friends

who simply gave everything he had & in the end even his very life

promising never to leave – a word which he still keeps



*****



to some this Vajra Guru thing will sound

like the senseless heroics of  a bygone age

or worse materialize like egomania incarnate



but then who listens to the habitual nay sayers

who insult ear & nose alike with their bad breath

shouting eternally returning slogans of fickleness



destined to be drowned

in the thundering waves of

the guru’s instructions



*****



may the laughing vajra shatter

such & every other birdbrain notion



apart from allowing the heart of hearts

to bloom from its centerless center



we don’t need to make a spectacle

& thus a nuisance of ourselves





© Choyin Dorje 2018






Sunday, September 2, 2018

Freedom Singing to Itself



Freedom is razor-sharp

the curved blade that cuts

the head off my neck

& lets the heart blood spout

fountain like



freedom is tender

            with my arms around you

as if they were feathers

            for the wool before my eyes

I cannot see one separate thing



freedom is boring

            going to the toilet

to shit & piss

            every morning looking in the mirror

probing for pimples on the nose



freedom is fire

            I hammer the blazing steel of the thoughts

that shackle everything

            only to have the acid of fear corrode

all that I ever grabbed & held

           

freedom is delicate

the dewdrop that falls
from the leaf above

            makes the web tremble

& the spider rope down further

             

freedom is despair

            no food on the table

with all the good people in chains

            while our leaders spit roast our hearts

to assuage their own fear of lack



freedom is desire

never getting

enough of it

when everything

is always there



freedom is sentimental

            my tears soak your pillow salty

of my being so very special

            as my is head remains stuck

I cannot explore the great blue yonder



freedom is straight & narrow

            deadlines 

timelines

fault lines –

            to bring about many a cleansing disaster



freedom is simply free

            no quality but its own

& there is stillness

            leaves burgeoning in spring

tumble to rot in november



essentially

even stupor is freedom

so is clinging

& so is hate



 knowing thus definitely freedom is
naturally self-affirming

projecting more of gossamer

subtly tremulous presence



I can drink my tea

I can sip my wine

every once in a while

I can look up in the sky



the thought doesn’t even arise

that anyone will ever not partake

in this heart of freedom

forever beating



the only question remains

does appreciation really require

some self mirroring voice

to sell freedom as more special than what is